And as is the case, there are two versions of the story:
The Ministry of Interior surprisingly opened a Twitter account last night and tweeted:
I know, it reads like a cartoon script, but that is the problem with 140-character messages, particularly those written by sci-fi writers.
Illegal rally in Karzakan 3 policemen attacked, Police had to fire 2 rubber buttons. 1st as warning shot 2nd bounced & hit a demonstrator
The other side paints a story of horror and gore, the use of excessive police brutality, casualties, and loads of tear gas, rubber bullets and shot guns - all documented with photographs being mass circulated on BBM, the Internet and word of mouth.
Bint Battuta in Bahrain translates the demands from the protests, starting across the country today here. And while most of them are legitimate, and something each decent Bahraini aspires to, a copy-cat revolution, with a Facebook event, is not what a sectarian divided Bahrain needs today.
These marches if anything will continue to fan the flames of sectarianism, pitting one neighbour against the other, in a country where mistrust between the two sects is becoming the trademark of our existence. We all know that the protests will be quashed. The riot police will not smile to the protesters and let them do their bit and go to their homes. There will be a crackdown, and it will be excessive, hard and brutal - but then every protester taking the streets already knows that.
Over the past few days I watched with horror as Bahrainis plummeted to the dark side, with new name tags on every ungrateful soul not drooling at the government and the scraps it throws at us to play fetch with. Fetch because whatever goes into one pocket, goes out the other. And play because even if one gesture or the other is genuine, the big picture shows that there is some big flaw in a reform project we all welcomed with open arms but are now becoming disillusioned with.
As you can see, I am not a huge fan of the government. I am also not a fan of stirring unrest in Bahrain. And I am also totally against the way the security forces will clampdown on any dissent or opposition - the same opposition I am not a fan of because of my liberal leanings, which don't mix well with the turban bearded mantra. But having said all this, my sympathy is with my country men and women, with the poor and needy, with those working hard to make ends meet, with those striving to have a roof on their heads, with those studying hard and eager to join the job market - with the decent Bahrainis out there who want to live in a land of equal opportunities and feel proud that they are Bahrainis - Just Bahraini, Not Sunni or Shia. (By the way, Just Bahraini - a bloggers initiative to fight sectarianism is BLOCKED by the Government of Bahrain!!!!)
What I am with is a civil dialogue and what I want to see today is the real Bahrainis standing up and stopping any bloodshed, anger and correcting the wrongs of the past. I also want to see goodwill and trust - trust from both the government and the people. I want us to believe and I want to be able to dream of a better Bahrain for my children. I want us all to give each other the benefit of the doubt and develop a capacity to listen to each other without calling each other unpatriotic, traitor or an agent of the West or Iran.
As Bahrainis, we need to sit down with each other and address our long list of woes, and work together on solving them. Sandwiched between Saudi Arabia and Iran, it would be foolish to demand a full democracy, with real emancipation, freedoms and citizens rights. I understand and accept that as this is my country and this is my destiny. What I do not accept and will never accept is the cesspit of sectarian bigotry we are drowning in.
The government needs to stop its games, the mental ones particularly, because all decent Bahrainis, Sunnis and Shia, are aware. The hoarse crow's caw will continue to reverberate but we will need to step out of the noise, call out corruption and rise above all the mistrust and work towards a common goal: A Bahrain we will all be proud to live in and work together for its progress and prosperity.
My own family and network of friends include people from the full spectrum of Bahrainis - Sunnis and Shias, those who spend more time in the Matams and mosques than with their families and those who cannot go a day without breaking one religious ruling or another - and we all live in peace, accepting each other and civil in the way we treat one another.
Having said all this: I will not march in the streets. I will stay put, surrounded by my cats and loved ones, hoping for peace in my restive country.
10 comments:
Bahrain; corrupt bloodthirsty puppet government
its sad whats going on in bahrain for all thier concerned citizens as its a special place in the gulf region.but i think the protesters have bitten more than they can chew as the ruling family in bahrain will not except to be browbeaten by the shia peasants into submission. and the other ruling families in the gulf dont want a precedent set for thier restive shia populations.the only way foward is dioalgue. question for all of you out there
are all or some Bahraini shia arabs or are they all of persians descent as from personal observation most people think the shia in bahrain are as they would say it iraniis or rather persian troublemakers
I like this post :) And i also encourage the fact that you lean towards supporting the helpless -who haven't had a heard voice for more than 200 years- regardless of your liberal beliefs.
Please read my blog post about Bahrain: www.bahrainifreedom.blogspot.com
Very well said indeed! Finally some words of reason and wisdom!
"No Hate. No Revenge" These should be the mantras today as Bahrain begins a long and arduous journey on the rough road of reconciliation and rehabilitation.
I am a former expat who left Bahrain 30 years back but still love the country probably as much as you do.
I wish you well.
Kamal
kamal.kothari@gmail.com
visit the pictures of Bahraini women supporting the revolution on:
http://hozourblog.wordpress.com/2011/03/12/bahraini-women-and-the-islamic-awakening-movement/
stay with your cats, and what you win for your country will be only something the price of which is staying with your cats!
human beings are dying on the streets of your country, Ms Liberal! think not that remaining silent does any good to Bahrain or anything else BUT your CATS!
I don't believe you are remaining silent; you have this interesting blog, for goodness sake! It is when people refuse to listen to and attempt to understand the opinions of others that strife occurs. I pray the people of Bahrain will come out of this in a good way. Thank you for encouraging cooperation and respect on all sides.
Quite a nice read and very well said indeed! Finally some words of reason and wisdom!
"No Hate. No Revenge"
This is sad.Hope everything fine for Bahrain.Love your blog
Follow each other.
Very nicely written. Its sad that you aren't writing anymore. The message you were conveying is exactly whats needed here to liquidate the hatred.
Post a Comment